Shipper’s guide

How to run a freight RFP with your forwarders

Two containers are leaving Jebel Ali. You need a forwarder who can meet the Rotterdam delivery window, and a price you can stand behind. Here’s what to ask before you choose.

Illustration of the container terminal where the example shipment begins.
Fictional shipment briefJebel Ali to RotterdamSea FCL · 2 × 40′ high cube · Quotes in AED

When do you need a freight RFP instead of an RFQ?

A request for quotation (RFQ) works when you can specify the service and need a price. If both containers must travel on a named sailing with an agreed scope, send each forwarder the same RFQ.

A request for proposal (RFP) gives forwarders room to propose the service too. For this UAE shipment, ask whether they would book a direct sailing or use a transshipment port. Have each explain how the schedule, destination free time and charges would affect your delivery window.

Forwarder checklist

What should you ask every forwarder?

Give every invited forwarder the same brief and reply deadline. Agree the delivery requirements with your receiving team before the first proposal arrives.

  1. Define the lane and scope.

    Specify Jebel Ali (AEJEA) to Rotterdam (NLRTM), two 40-foot high cubes, the commodity, gross weight, cargo-ready date and latest acceptable arrival. State the Incoterm and which collection, port and delivery legs to price.

  2. Ask for a sailing plan.

    Request the carrier, routing, cut-off, transit time and free days at destination. If a connection is involved, ask what happens if the first vessel misses it. Ask how the forwarder counts free days at destination.

  3. Give each charge a unit.

    Request ocean freight per container and documentation per shipment in AED. Ask the forwarder to identify included charges, exclusions and anything billed at cost, then state how long the rates are valid. See how an invited forwarder prepares and submits a quote.

  4. Set the decision and reply rules.

    Give a deadline in Gulf Standard Time (UTC+4). Say how you will assess timing and cost, who handles questions and when forwarders should expect your decision. Share any change to the brief with everyone.

Worked example

How do you compare the proposals?

First check whether each sailing meets your delivery window and includes the legs you requested. For the offers that qualify, compare the same two containers on a net basis, excluding VAT.

In this fictional round, Tavrilo has the smaller confirmed charge. Its final position depends on the ocean freight invoice. Ask for a cap or a firm rate if that uncertainty could change your choice.

See when the lower bid changes

JEBEL ALI → ROTTERDAM

The two offers at a glance

Orvessa Cargo2 × AED 100 freight + AED 50 documentation
AED 250
quoted net
Tavrilo FreightAED 70 documentation + ocean freight at cost
AED 70
confirmed

At an estimated AED 150 per container, Tavrilo reaches AED 370. Record that assumption with the sailing you chose so your team can revisit the decision.

Jebel Ali → Rotterdam · Buyer’s example

How should you score freight forwarder proposals?

The receiver needs both containers by 24 June. Rule out any proposal that misses that date or omits a required leg. Both fictional offers qualify, but only one leaves time to recover from a delay.

Two forwarders scored out of 100
CriterionOrvessa CargoTavrilo Freight
Comparable net40AED 250 fixed27AED 370 estimated
Delivery buffer1024 June3522 June
Recovery plan0No fallback specified15Backup sailing and rebooking plan
Free time55 terminal days107 terminal days
Total55 / 10087 / 100

Tavrilo leads by 32 points. Its estimated premium is AED 120 for the shipment. That buys two days of delivery buffer, a documented fallback and two extra free days.

Before selecting Tavrilo, ask for a firm ocean rate or cap, the carrier’s sailing details and written free-time terms. If those change, update the affected rows and score both offers again.

Agree the points before bids arrive

Price · 40 points
Divide the lowest comparable net by the offer’s comparable net, multiply by 40 and round to the nearest whole point.
Delivery buffer · 35 points
A proposed delivery at least two days early earns 35 points, one day early earns 20 and on the deadline earns 10.
Recovery plan · 15 points
A named alternative sailing and a written rebooking plan earn 15 points. An unspecified fallback earns zero.
Destination free time · 10 points
For the same terminal events, seven or more free calendar days earn 10 points, five or six earn 5 and fewer earn zero.

Ready to request prices?

Send the same Sea FCL brief to your shortlisted forwarders. When the quotes come back, put them side by side in the comparison workbook.